Isoperimetric Problems Explained with Worked Examples

An isoperimetric problem asks for the function that makes stationary subject to a fixed value of another integral . The solution makes stationary, where is a constant (a Lagrange multiplier).

Write 2x or 2*x to multiply, ^ for powers, and ; between simultaneous equations. You can also type factor, expand, derivative of, integrate … from a to b, limit … as x->0 or 15% of 80.

Try an example

Before you start

This page is easier if you are comfortable with:

What Isoperimetric (constrained) problems means

The classical problem is to find the closed curve of given length that encloses the largest area; the answer is a circle. The multiplier is fixed by the constraint. The method is the calculus-of-variations counterpart of constrained optimisation with a multiplier, which also appears in KKT conditions and Lagrangian duality; it uses the Euler–Lagrange equation for the combined integrand.

For a perimeter : a circle has area , a regular hexagon , a square , and an equilateral triangle . The isoperimetric quotient equals 1 for the circle and for the square. The comparison of shapes uses the area of a circle and the circumference of a circle.

The same idea gives the shape of a hanging chain of fixed length (the catenary, found with the Beltrami identity) and many optimal-shape problems in physics. A related inequality in the plane is the isoperimetric inequality ; compare AM–GM-type results for rectangles, where a square maximises area for a given perimeter.

What is it used for?

For a fixed perimeter, the circle encloses the largest area. Isoperimetric problems find the best shape under a fixed constraint.

How to use isoperimetric (constrained) problems

  1. Write the quantity to optimise and the constraint, and constant.
  2. Form and apply the Euler–Lagrange equation to .
  3. Solve, then use the constraint to find .
  4. Check the solution against other shapes.

Graph

Areas enclosed by a boundary of length 20triangle 19.2square 25hexagon 28.9circle 31.800.511.522.533.544.5505101520253035Areas enclosed by a boundary of length 20shapeyGraph with x from 0 to 5 and y from 0 to 36. Shows bars (4); point triangle 19.2 at (1, 19.245); point square 25 at (2, 25); point hexagon 28.9 at (3, 28.868); point circle 31.8 at (4, 31.831).

More sides get closer to the circle, which has the greatest area.

Worked examples

These examples are worked by hand, step by step, so you can compare your own working.

Example 1: circle area

Find the area of a circle whose perimeter is 20.

Worked example
Answer
100π≈31.83\dfrac{100}{\pi}\approx31.83
  1. Radius
  2. Area

Example 2: square area

Find the area of the square with perimeter 20 and compare with the circle.

Worked example
Answer
2525
  1. Side
  2. Area
  3. Ratio to the circle

Example 3: hexagon

Find the area of a regular hexagon with perimeter 20.

Worked example
Answer
28.8728.87
  1. Side
  2. Area

Special cases

A few situations come up again and again. Knowing them saves time and helps you spot answers that cannot be right.

Perimeter 20, circle

r = 20/(2π)

3.1831.

Circle area

πr²

31.831.

Square, side 5

area

25.

Ratio circle/square

31.831/25

1.2732.

Word problems

Among closed curves of fixed length L the circle encloses the greatest area A = L²/(4π). Isoperimetric problems use ∫(F + λG)dx with a multiplier λ.

Radius

Perimeter 20. Find r = L/2π.

  1. 20/6.2832
  2. Check: ✓3.1831

Circle area

Find πr².

  1. π × 10.132
  2. Check: ✓31.831

Square comparison Higher

Square of perimeter 20: area?

  1. 5²
  2. Check: ✓25

Ratio Higher

Circle area ÷ square area.

  1. 31.831/25
  2. Check: ✓1.2732

Common mistakes

Square is optimal

wrong ✗

circle ✓

Maximum area.

r = L/π

wrong ✗

L/2π ✓

Circumference 2πr.

Forgetting the constraint

ignored ✗

fixed length ✓

Multiplier λ.

Area = L²/4π

forgot ✗

A = L²/(4π) ✓

Formula.

Exam tips

  1. Circle maximises area.
  2. A = L²/4π.
  3. Multiplier λ.
  4. Compare with a square.
  5. Constraint ∫G = const.

Practice questions

Try each one on paper, then open the answer. Use the solver above to see the full working.

1. Circle area, L = 10 to 3 d.p. Foundation

7.958

2. Square area, L = 10 Foundation

6.25

3. r for L = 6π Foundation

3

4. Circle area, L = 4π Higher

12.566

5. L² / 4π for L = 8 to 4 d.p. Higher

5.093

6. Square area, L = 20 Higher

25

Practice generator

Unlimited fresh questions with instant marking. Choose a level, work it out on paper, then type your answer.

Solve: …

Key terms

Isoperimetric problem
Optimise with a fixed constraint.
Lagrange multiplier (λ)
Constraint weight.
Circle
Optimal shape.
Perimeter (L)
Fixed length.
Constraint
∫G dx = const.
Isoperimetric inequality
L² ≥ 4πA.

Frequently asked questions

What is the isoperimetric problem?

Maximise enclosed area for a fixed perimeter.

What is the solution?

A circle.

What is the inequality?

L² ≥ 4πA.

What role does λ play?

It enforces the constraint.

Which page covers the Beltrami identity?

Beltrami identity.

Which page covers Hamilton’s equations?

Hamilton’s equations.

More in Analysis, algebra and topology and the formula sheets.